| Message ID | 20210111130557.90208-1-hui.wang@canonical.com (mailing list archive) |
|---|---|
| Headers | show |
| Series | design a way to change audio Jack state by software | expand |
Hi Takashi, Looks like no more comment from others, what is your opinion on the patchset, is it ok to merge or need to do some change? Thanks, Hui. On 1/11/21 9:05 PM, Hui Wang wrote: > the changes in the v4: > - change the sound-core to sound and change the sound_core_debugfs_root > to sound_debugfs_root in the 0001-xxx.patch > - change kzalloc/kfree to kvzalloc/kvfree in the debugfs fops for > 0001-xxx.patch and 0003-xxx.patch > - And if needed, I could squash 4 patches into 1 patch before merging. > > the changes in the v3 (for easy to review, divide change into 4 patches): > - address the comment about the snd_jack_report() and _snd_jack_report(), > the v2 design is hard to understand and is hard to review, in the v3, > separate the jack_report to snd_jack_report() and snd_jack_inject_report(), > hw jack events call snd_jack_report() as before, if a jack contains multi > jack_kctl and the jack_kctl's sw_inject is enabled, the status and the > related input-dev's events will not be reproted. The injection events call > snd_jack_inject_report(). This change is squashed to 0001-xxx.patch, the > rest part of 0001-xxx.patch is same as v2. > > - address the comment about folders'name in the 0002-xxx.patch, so far, drop > the '/', ',', '=' and ' ' from the folders' name. > > - address the comment about adding more debugfs nodes in the 0003-xxx.patch, > it adds kctl_id, mask_bits, status and type. > > - address the comment about save-n-restore jack's hw status in the > 0004-xxx.patch, adding a hw_status_cache and save the last reported jack > hw event, once the sw_inject is disabled, will restore all jack_kctl's > state under the same snd_jack with hw_status_cache. > [snip] > > > the changes in the V2: > - using debugfs instead of sysfs > - using jack_ctrl to create a folder instead of snd_jack, since ASoC drivers > could create multi jack_ctrls within a snd_jack > - create a folder for each jack_ctrl instead for all jack_ctrls > [ snip ] > > > Hui Wang (4): > alsa: jack: implement software jack injection via debugfs > alsa: jack: adjust jack_kctl debugfs folder's name > alsa: jack: add more jack_kctl debugfs nodes > alsa: jack: implement save-and-restore for jack's hw status > > include/sound/core.h | 2 + > include/sound/jack.h | 1 + > sound/core/init.c | 7 + > sound/core/jack.c | 352 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++- > sound/core/sound.c | 8 + > 5 files changed, 366 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) >
On Wed, 20 Jan 2021 09:58:25 +0100, Hui Wang wrote: > > Hi Takashi, > > Looks like no more comment from others, what is your opinion on the > patchset, is it ok to merge or need to do some change? I think the basic concept is OK. Maybe we want to have a Kconfig to enable/disable this feature for users who want a slim kernel. And, it'd be better to reorganize the series. It's not necessarily incremental form; e.g. patch 2 doesn't have to be an individual patch. I'll take a deeper look for each patch, too. thanks, Takashi > > Thanks, > > Hui. > > On 1/11/21 9:05 PM, Hui Wang wrote: > > the changes in the v4: > > - change the sound-core to sound and change the sound_core_debugfs_root > > to sound_debugfs_root in the 0001-xxx.patch > > - change kzalloc/kfree to kvzalloc/kvfree in the debugfs fops for > > 0001-xxx.patch and 0003-xxx.patch > > - And if needed, I could squash 4 patches into 1 patch before merging. > > > > the changes in the v3 (for easy to review, divide change into 4 patches): > > - address the comment about the snd_jack_report() and _snd_jack_report(), > > the v2 design is hard to understand and is hard to review, in the v3, > > separate the jack_report to snd_jack_report() and snd_jack_inject_report(), > > hw jack events call snd_jack_report() as before, if a jack contains multi > > jack_kctl and the jack_kctl's sw_inject is enabled, the status and the > > related input-dev's events will not be reproted. The injection events call > > snd_jack_inject_report(). This change is squashed to 0001-xxx.patch, the > > rest part of 0001-xxx.patch is same as v2. > > > > - address the comment about folders'name in the 0002-xxx.patch, so far, drop > > the '/', ',', '=' and ' ' from the folders' name. > > > > - address the comment about adding more debugfs nodes in the 0003-xxx.patch, > > it adds kctl_id, mask_bits, status and type. > > > > - address the comment about save-n-restore jack's hw status in the > > 0004-xxx.patch, adding a hw_status_cache and save the last reported jack > > hw event, once the sw_inject is disabled, will restore all jack_kctl's > > state under the same snd_jack with hw_status_cache. > > [snip] > > > > > > the changes in the V2: > > - using debugfs instead of sysfs > > - using jack_ctrl to create a folder instead of snd_jack, since ASoC drivers > > could create multi jack_ctrls within a snd_jack > > - create a folder for each jack_ctrl instead for all jack_ctrls > > [ snip ] > > > > > > Hui Wang (4): > > alsa: jack: implement software jack injection via debugfs > > alsa: jack: adjust jack_kctl debugfs folder's name > > alsa: jack: add more jack_kctl debugfs nodes > > alsa: jack: implement save-and-restore for jack's hw status > > > > include/sound/core.h | 2 + > > include/sound/jack.h | 1 + > > sound/core/init.c | 7 + > > sound/core/jack.c | 352 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++- > > sound/core/sound.c | 8 + > > 5 files changed, 366 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) > > >
On 1/20/21 10:47 PM, Takashi Iwai wrote: > On Wed, 20 Jan 2021 09:58:25 +0100, > Hui Wang wrote: >> Hi Takashi, >> >> Looks like no more comment from others, what is your opinion on the >> patchset, is it ok to merge or need to do some change? > I think the basic concept is OK. Maybe we want to have a Kconfig to > enable/disable this feature for users who want a slim kernel. > > And, it'd be better to reorganize the series. It's not necessarily > incremental form; e.g. patch 2 doesn't have to be an individual > patch. > > I'll take a deeper look for each patch, too. > > > thanks, > > Takashi > Got it, will address all comments, and will send a v5 to review soon. Thanks, Hui. > > > >> Thanks, >> >> Hui. >> >> On 1/11/21 9:05 PM, Hui Wang wrote: >>> the changes in the v4: >>> - change the sound-core to sound and change the sound_core_debugfs_root >>> to sound_debugfs_root in the 0001-xxx.patch >>> - change kzalloc/kfree to kvzalloc/kvfree in the debugfs fops for >>> 0001-xxx.patch and 0003-xxx.patch >>> - And if needed, I could squash 4 patches into 1 patch before merging. >>> >>> the changes in the v3 (for easy to review, divide change into 4 patches): >>> - address the comment about the snd_jack_report() and _snd_jack_report(), >>> the v2 design is hard to understand and is hard to review, in the v3, >>> separate the jack_report to snd_jack_report() and snd_jack_inject_report(), >>> hw jack events call snd_jack_report() as before, if a jack contains multi >>> jack_kctl and the jack_kctl's sw_inject is enabled, the status and the >>> related input-dev's events will not be reproted. The injection events call >>> snd_jack_inject_report(). This change is squashed to 0001-xxx.patch, the >>> rest part of 0001-xxx.patch is same as v2. >>> >>> - address the comment about folders'name in the 0002-xxx.patch, so far, drop >>> the '/', ',', '=' and ' ' from the folders' name. >>> >>> - address the comment about adding more debugfs nodes in the 0003-xxx.patch, >>> it adds kctl_id, mask_bits, status and type. >>> >>> - address the comment about save-n-restore jack's hw status in the >>> 0004-xxx.patch, adding a hw_status_cache and save the last reported jack >>> hw event, once the sw_inject is disabled, will restore all jack_kctl's >>> state under the same snd_jack with hw_status_cache. >>> [snip] >>> >>> >>> the changes in the V2: >>> - using debugfs instead of sysfs >>> - using jack_ctrl to create a folder instead of snd_jack, since ASoC drivers >>> could create multi jack_ctrls within a snd_jack >>> - create a folder for each jack_ctrl instead for all jack_ctrls >>> [ snip ] >>> >>> >>> Hui Wang (4): >>> alsa: jack: implement software jack injection via debugfs >>> alsa: jack: adjust jack_kctl debugfs folder's name >>> alsa: jack: add more jack_kctl debugfs nodes >>> alsa: jack: implement save-and-restore for jack's hw status >>> >>> include/sound/core.h | 2 + >>> include/sound/jack.h | 1 + >>> sound/core/init.c | 7 + >>> sound/core/jack.c | 352 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++- >>> sound/core/sound.c | 8 + >>> 5 files changed, 366 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) >>>